Synopsis:
A great evil stirs in Tokyo after sunset. The dragon stream has been disrupted, unleashing legions of demonic forces on the city that prowl the night and turn their victims into the living dead. Fortunately, this rupture in the flow of paranormal energy has also endowed a handful of teenagers with superpowered abilities, and they must use them to keep the demons at bay and restore order to the dragon stream. However, they aren't the only ones to inherit these new abilities. Crazed revolutionaries and vengeful youths share their own demonic powers with normal humans to ensnare the team of fighters and make the world their own. The five teens must band together and seek the help of other magic-users to protect the ones they love from a worldwide demon apocalypse.
Review:
Tokyo Majin is so very messy, in every sense of the word. Innocent schoolgirls get dragged screaming into the clutches of slime-spewing zombies, fighters clash and tear each other apart, spilling intestines and exposing bone, and juvenile delinquents morph into animalistic monsters or melt into rotting flesh-piles episode by episode. This series does not hold back on presenting every gnarly little detail of its bloodbaths.
Unfortunately, the plot is also a big mess. It's not entirely impossible to follow, but it's schizophrenic enough that viewers are liable to feel slighted for paying so much attention to the current set of villainous plots only for them to be supplanted by a new threat that has little to do with anything that occurred before. The two seasons of the series are separated into a “Dark Arts Chapter” and a “Martial Fist Chapter” but the number of antagonists and their pawns is far more than two; sometimes it feels like more than twenty. The number of ways the dragon stream's power can be employed is ridiculously infinite. Every eastern mythology from the twin dragons of yin and yang to the four beast guardians to fantastic retellings of historical events like the Meiji Restoration is pulled in and used at random to set up new confusing conflicts to squeeze into the plot. If there is an overall plot, that is, but it seems more like the writers are making it up as they go along. The climactic battle with the final villain arrives out of nowhere in the last few episodes, and the fact that the anime is based off a series of Playstation games is probably to blame.
The characters aren't impressive enough to compensate for this either, unfortunately. There is potential for growth in the main cast, but for the most part they remain “the shy bishi,” “the bad boy,” “the sweet girl,” “the tomboy,” and “the softhearted bigun.” Not to mention their shadowy sixth member: “Mr. Exposition.” Sweet girl Aoi and shy bishi Tatsuma get the most attention as they are hiding the most volatile superpowers, but the other four get just enough fleshing out to qualify them as equally leading roles…equally barely dimensional. Piled on top of these so-so protagonists are dozens of cardboard cutout NPCs that rob far more screentime than they should and only add to the confusion of the overstuffed storyblob.
Tokyo Majin does not know how to tell a comprehensible story. What it thankfully does know how to do is put on a wild, bloody show. For as many unneeded characters as there are running around, the character designs are very distinct and flexible. It is impossible to mistake one character for another even in the tertiary roles like the recurring young mortician and old detective pair or innumerable sensei figures. The animation is likewise quite impressive. The fights can be a little jerky and hard-edged, but retain fluidity where it counts, and the choreography for each bizarre new brawl is unique enough to merit rewatching the battles. Supporting the fights is a score as schizophrenic as the storyline, but with much more positive results. The score dances from techno beats to screaming punk rock to sweet orchestral ballads and fits each scene appropriately without ever calling attention to itself, (with the exception of a few insert songs by punk group ACID, who also performed the OP and ED themes.) The high entertainment value of each gory clash, and they are near-constant, almost makes up for the rotten story…almost.
The writing isn't rotten all the way through, mind you, and the story is most effective when it dives into its fighters' pasts. While not the most well-developed demon hunters, they have surprisingly engaging backstories to share, particularly the berserker Daigo's arc, and Tatsuma's romantic forays, both of which are downright tear-jerking. Emotionally, the series hits some very effective highs, but it's necessary to keep your brain switched off to get any enjoyment out of the overall result. Not much more can be said for a series whose final battle is nearly ten solid minutes of blasting ki and shattering sternums.
The emotional overdrive the series carries (lots and lots of screaming and swearing) is supported well by both casts. The Japanese track is capably strong with a good balance of seasoned seiyuu, and Yui Horie filling out Aoi's role perfectly in her shy whispers and angry outbursts. ADV's dub is extremely faithful, save for being peppered with more obscenities and appropriate colloquialisms. As there are no standouts in the cast itself, there are no real standouts in performance, but all the voice actors from a handful of newbies to a buffer of familiar voices put forth a solid effort that hits the mark just right scene by scene. Outside of the leads, Vic Mignogna plays season one's head villain Kozunu frighteningly well in all his silky-tongued, psychotic glory. He's doubtless the most engaging villain of the series, aided greatly by such a creepy dub performance.
Overall Tokyo Majin's narrative fails to stand out in any regard, and more often than not, it just embarrasses itself and falls into a cluster of contrived RPG-style plot threads, jumping from confusing scene to confusing scene with no overall direction. It's horrid. Still, it never ceases to hold attention for some strange reason. Visually, it's provocative, arresting, gory and wild. (Have you ever seen a series where a human hornet's nest goes around tearing off people's arms while insects crawl out of her skin and burrow into theirs?) At least for a brainless round of beat-em-ups, it hits all the right spots.
Grade:
Overall (dub) : C+
Overall (sub) : C+
Story : D+
Animation : B+
Art : B+
Music : B+
+ Wildly entertaining action blowouts, some emotional whammies
− Story is a barely comprehensible mess, bloated cast of flat stereotypes
2010/09/06
The Anime Review : Tokyo Majin DVD - Complete Series
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
new anime,
the anime review,
Tokyo Majin review,
top anime
The Anime Review : To Love Ru DVD - Collection 1
Synopsis:
Poor Rito Yuuki; he not only has trouble working up the nerve to confess to classmate Haruna, the apple of his eye, but Fate itself also seems out to get him every time he gets close. The biggest and most problematic of these disruptions to come along is the gorgeous, tail-sporting alien princess Lala Satalin Deviluke, who first appears, completely naked, in his bathtub while running away from her father. Misinterpreting Rito's initial actions as a marriage proposal (planet Deviluke apparently has some strange ideas about this), Lala latches onto Rito as her fiancé, partly because she fell in love with him over his attempts to protect her from villains he thought were trying to kidnap her and partly to give herself an excuse to dodge the other marriage proposals she's constantly beset by. She sets up house with Rito and his younger sister and eventually goes to school with him, too, which naturally causes no small amount of complications for Rito, but even having such a sexy girl almost literally hanging on him doesn't discourage him from trying to win Haruna – and she seems interested, too, when he isn't accidentally groping her.
Being the fiancé of a Deviluke princess also attracts a lot of unwanted attention. Rito regularly finds himself beset by rivals for Lala's hand, zealous fan club presidents, assassins, earnest bodyguards, jealous fellow students, and alien cooking ingredients run wild. Lala's antics even run Rito afoul of the school's resident Morals Officer. What's a young man with so many beauties at hand, who practically blows his top when faced with such lusciousness, to do?
Review:
The name of this series, which is based on a manga written by Saki Hasemi and drawn by Black Cat creator Kentaro Yabuki, is a pun based on the similar ways “love” and “trouble” sound when spoken with Japanese syllables and is meant to be representative of the kind of trouble that love brings the main character in the story. That's as subtle as this series ever gets, however. Within the first couple of seconds the opener establishes the tone for the series by showing Lala, the main hottie, cheerily prancing around topless (albeit with strategically-placed hands), and that is only the beginning. What follows in this release are thirteen episodes of unabashedly trashy entertainment which do not even pretend that they are about anything more than rampant fan service and cheap laughs. But sometimes that approach works, and this is one of those cases.
Appreciating the merits of this one does require wading through a lot of faults, however. To call To Love-Ru derivative might be an understatement; its content is, essentially, a conglomeration of structures and gimmicks common to male-oriented romantic comedies put out over the past three decades. An unassuming but good-hearted guy has a gorgeous alien princess fall in love with him and seek to wed him? Yeah, that's never been done more than, oh, about a thousand times before, and this one is not any fresher a variation than any previous iteration. (The most unfortunate legacy of Urusei Yatsura lives on!) Girl first appears in the guy's tub while he's taking a bath? Been there, done that. Despite having a difficult time staying cool around women, guy gets practically swarmed by them? That, too, is also trite, although at least Rito does not get nosebleeds. Unfortunate circumstances constantly put guy in a position to accidentally grope his love interest or bury his face in a girl's crotch? Yeah, you could name about any romantic comedy of the past decade. Hot nurse who wears fantastically school-inappropriate clothing? That's practically a uniform requirement for schools in Japan, isn't it? Haughty “Queen of the School” type who feels threatened by the guy's woman? See Ah! My Goddess. Character who changes gender in certain stressful situations? See Ranma ½, although this is a more extreme case. And so on and so forth. Little of what the series has done so far has even a shred of originality to it. And can we ever get a male lead in one of these who is bold enough to take advantage when a sexy, naked girl keeps crawling into his bed at night?
So what makes something like this actually watchable? Despite its many flaws, it is often quite funny in those little moments where it steps beyond normal anime romantic comedy schlock. The otherwise-weak first episode shows some of the series' comedic potential by keeping Rito from confessing to Haruna on one occasion because he gets trampled by a random herd of elephants – in the middle of a Japanese city, no less. It takes bolder steps forward in the second episode with Zastin, the armored guy, who spent the first episode looking like he was going to be the irritating Overprotective Guy stereotype but instead, shockingly, starts showing great comic timing; one later scene involving something going awry for him during an apparently-serious fight will make almost anyone giggle despite themselves. A later scene involving Lala's cooking ingredients getting out of hand is a hoot, as are most of the bizarre suitors (especially the Rocketman-type alien and his problems with a certain dog) and many of Rito's fantasies. And when Lala's immensely powerful father finally makes an appearance in episode 13 – well, that is a surprise that should not be spoiled, but it will either make you sputter or roll your eyes. The series even has the savvy to play Rito's impossibly good-natured side up for laughs at one point.
Fan service also stands in the series' favor, as it certainly does not lack in quantity when it comes to near-nudity, panty flashes, ripped clothing, sexy outfits, groping, and even some highly suggestive scenes involving tentacles, shibari techniques, and one of the more sexual uniform transformation scenes you'll ever see outside of a hentai title (although, mercifully that only gets used a couple of times early on); it even liberally layers the fan service across the visuals of its eyecatches and both its opener and its closer. The quality of the fan service matters just as much, though. Lala may be an irrepressibly cheery airhead with some very bizarre inventions at her disposal, but she is also damn fine-looking naked and the series gives you ample opportunities to appreciate that. Most other girls also get their turns in some stages of undress, and rarely do they disappoint. The series even toys with self-censorship by typically adding in just enough mist or haziness to avoid outright nipple shots while still sometimes allowing hints of visible areolas. Those looking for a fully uncensored version will be disappointed, though.
The series also has fan service of other forms. Although references to other anime are sparse – the only obvious ones in these episodes are to Dragon Ball, Black Cat, and Gundam Seed – numerous other American and Japanese pop culture references can be spotted by sharp-eyed viewers. The opening scenes of the first episode have a very Star Wars flavor, chunks of one episode parody the American movies Rocky and Karate Kid, one of Lala's costumes in episode 3 looks suspiciously like Snow White's dress, dream sequences parody a Japanese flavor of stand-up comedy in one episode, and a sly reference or two to ero games might be noted, among other things. The series is nowhere near as stocked with this content as is a Hayate the Combat Butler, but it is there.
The look of the series is certainly not a negative, except for a series-opening sequence which looks like something left over from late '80s cell animation. The artistry clearly focuses its effort on the design and rendering of its female characters; Lala is the outright sexiest (although that made-for-cosplay costume has got to go), but the more petite Haruna has plenty of her own appeal and Rito's sister Mikan has that “I'm going to be a knock-out when I'm a few years older” kind of appeal to her. Prefer the loli look? The assassin Golden Darkness, with all of her buckles, provides that. Almost none of the other female characters will be found lacking, either. Male character designs get decidedly less attention, often even looking dumpy, with Zastin being the rare exception. The CG effects are quite sharp and virtually seamless in application; studio Xebec has outdone itself in that aspect. They did not put anywhere near as much effort into the background art or animation, though.
The musical score is most distinctive for a strong set of opener and closer. "forever we can make it!" by THYME is a strong J-Rock opener paired with some clever Japanese credit placements in its fan service shots. (For instance, one of the credits is tanned inside the tan line of one female character's swimsuit, which she has pulled back to reveal, while another set is on a shirt washing instructions tag.) Closer “Lucky Tune” by ANNA offers an equally catchy, upbeat J-Pop number featuring bubble patterns flashing over Lala in various model-like poses. The soundtrack in between ranges from remarkably bland to quite lively depending on the scene, working best with the heavier rock pieces used for some action scenes and the high-energy synthesized number used when things are going comically amiss and least effectively in the lower-key scene-backing tunes.
Sentai Filmworks ' release of the title puts the thirteen episodes on two disks in a regular-sized case in a facing-each-other packaging arrangement which makes each disk convenient to handle – by far the best packing arrangement of any American company currently releasing two-disk cases. The only Extras, as per the recent norm for Sentai, are clean opener and closer, and the former actually suffers for not having the credits included. (It makes some of the zoom shots seem pointless.) The Subtitle Mistake count for this set is at two, both on the second disk and both involving an accidental replacement of the obviously-correct word with a similarly-spelled incorrect word. Also curiously, one of the menus for the first disk features a character who does not appear until a second-disk episode. As per the norm, there is no English dub and the opener and closer are both the Japanese originals, with English credits only at the very end of each episode.
To Love-Ru was definitely not created with a female audience in mind. It is a series squarely aimed at male otaku, and does exactly what it intends to do: deliver a lot of fan service and a good number of effective laughs. That makes any arguments about how lowbrow or derivative it is largely irrelevant.
Grade:
Overall (sub) : B-
Story : C+
Animation : C+
Art : B
Music : B
+ Plentiful quality fan service, sometimes quite funny, opener and closer.
− Depends too heavily on overused genre elements, some jokes fall flat.
Poor Rito Yuuki; he not only has trouble working up the nerve to confess to classmate Haruna, the apple of his eye, but Fate itself also seems out to get him every time he gets close. The biggest and most problematic of these disruptions to come along is the gorgeous, tail-sporting alien princess Lala Satalin Deviluke, who first appears, completely naked, in his bathtub while running away from her father. Misinterpreting Rito's initial actions as a marriage proposal (planet Deviluke apparently has some strange ideas about this), Lala latches onto Rito as her fiancé, partly because she fell in love with him over his attempts to protect her from villains he thought were trying to kidnap her and partly to give herself an excuse to dodge the other marriage proposals she's constantly beset by. She sets up house with Rito and his younger sister and eventually goes to school with him, too, which naturally causes no small amount of complications for Rito, but even having such a sexy girl almost literally hanging on him doesn't discourage him from trying to win Haruna – and she seems interested, too, when he isn't accidentally groping her.
Being the fiancé of a Deviluke princess also attracts a lot of unwanted attention. Rito regularly finds himself beset by rivals for Lala's hand, zealous fan club presidents, assassins, earnest bodyguards, jealous fellow students, and alien cooking ingredients run wild. Lala's antics even run Rito afoul of the school's resident Morals Officer. What's a young man with so many beauties at hand, who practically blows his top when faced with such lusciousness, to do?
Review:
The name of this series, which is based on a manga written by Saki Hasemi and drawn by Black Cat creator Kentaro Yabuki, is a pun based on the similar ways “love” and “trouble” sound when spoken with Japanese syllables and is meant to be representative of the kind of trouble that love brings the main character in the story. That's as subtle as this series ever gets, however. Within the first couple of seconds the opener establishes the tone for the series by showing Lala, the main hottie, cheerily prancing around topless (albeit with strategically-placed hands), and that is only the beginning. What follows in this release are thirteen episodes of unabashedly trashy entertainment which do not even pretend that they are about anything more than rampant fan service and cheap laughs. But sometimes that approach works, and this is one of those cases.
Appreciating the merits of this one does require wading through a lot of faults, however. To call To Love-Ru derivative might be an understatement; its content is, essentially, a conglomeration of structures and gimmicks common to male-oriented romantic comedies put out over the past three decades. An unassuming but good-hearted guy has a gorgeous alien princess fall in love with him and seek to wed him? Yeah, that's never been done more than, oh, about a thousand times before, and this one is not any fresher a variation than any previous iteration. (The most unfortunate legacy of Urusei Yatsura lives on!) Girl first appears in the guy's tub while he's taking a bath? Been there, done that. Despite having a difficult time staying cool around women, guy gets practically swarmed by them? That, too, is also trite, although at least Rito does not get nosebleeds. Unfortunate circumstances constantly put guy in a position to accidentally grope his love interest or bury his face in a girl's crotch? Yeah, you could name about any romantic comedy of the past decade. Hot nurse who wears fantastically school-inappropriate clothing? That's practically a uniform requirement for schools in Japan, isn't it? Haughty “Queen of the School” type who feels threatened by the guy's woman? See Ah! My Goddess. Character who changes gender in certain stressful situations? See Ranma ½, although this is a more extreme case. And so on and so forth. Little of what the series has done so far has even a shred of originality to it. And can we ever get a male lead in one of these who is bold enough to take advantage when a sexy, naked girl keeps crawling into his bed at night?
So what makes something like this actually watchable? Despite its many flaws, it is often quite funny in those little moments where it steps beyond normal anime romantic comedy schlock. The otherwise-weak first episode shows some of the series' comedic potential by keeping Rito from confessing to Haruna on one occasion because he gets trampled by a random herd of elephants – in the middle of a Japanese city, no less. It takes bolder steps forward in the second episode with Zastin, the armored guy, who spent the first episode looking like he was going to be the irritating Overprotective Guy stereotype but instead, shockingly, starts showing great comic timing; one later scene involving something going awry for him during an apparently-serious fight will make almost anyone giggle despite themselves. A later scene involving Lala's cooking ingredients getting out of hand is a hoot, as are most of the bizarre suitors (especially the Rocketman-type alien and his problems with a certain dog) and many of Rito's fantasies. And when Lala's immensely powerful father finally makes an appearance in episode 13 – well, that is a surprise that should not be spoiled, but it will either make you sputter or roll your eyes. The series even has the savvy to play Rito's impossibly good-natured side up for laughs at one point.
Fan service also stands in the series' favor, as it certainly does not lack in quantity when it comes to near-nudity, panty flashes, ripped clothing, sexy outfits, groping, and even some highly suggestive scenes involving tentacles, shibari techniques, and one of the more sexual uniform transformation scenes you'll ever see outside of a hentai title (although, mercifully that only gets used a couple of times early on); it even liberally layers the fan service across the visuals of its eyecatches and both its opener and its closer. The quality of the fan service matters just as much, though. Lala may be an irrepressibly cheery airhead with some very bizarre inventions at her disposal, but she is also damn fine-looking naked and the series gives you ample opportunities to appreciate that. Most other girls also get their turns in some stages of undress, and rarely do they disappoint. The series even toys with self-censorship by typically adding in just enough mist or haziness to avoid outright nipple shots while still sometimes allowing hints of visible areolas. Those looking for a fully uncensored version will be disappointed, though.
The series also has fan service of other forms. Although references to other anime are sparse – the only obvious ones in these episodes are to Dragon Ball, Black Cat, and Gundam Seed – numerous other American and Japanese pop culture references can be spotted by sharp-eyed viewers. The opening scenes of the first episode have a very Star Wars flavor, chunks of one episode parody the American movies Rocky and Karate Kid, one of Lala's costumes in episode 3 looks suspiciously like Snow White's dress, dream sequences parody a Japanese flavor of stand-up comedy in one episode, and a sly reference or two to ero games might be noted, among other things. The series is nowhere near as stocked with this content as is a Hayate the Combat Butler, but it is there.
The look of the series is certainly not a negative, except for a series-opening sequence which looks like something left over from late '80s cell animation. The artistry clearly focuses its effort on the design and rendering of its female characters; Lala is the outright sexiest (although that made-for-cosplay costume has got to go), but the more petite Haruna has plenty of her own appeal and Rito's sister Mikan has that “I'm going to be a knock-out when I'm a few years older” kind of appeal to her. Prefer the loli look? The assassin Golden Darkness, with all of her buckles, provides that. Almost none of the other female characters will be found lacking, either. Male character designs get decidedly less attention, often even looking dumpy, with Zastin being the rare exception. The CG effects are quite sharp and virtually seamless in application; studio Xebec has outdone itself in that aspect. They did not put anywhere near as much effort into the background art or animation, though.
The musical score is most distinctive for a strong set of opener and closer. "forever we can make it!" by THYME is a strong J-Rock opener paired with some clever Japanese credit placements in its fan service shots. (For instance, one of the credits is tanned inside the tan line of one female character's swimsuit, which she has pulled back to reveal, while another set is on a shirt washing instructions tag.) Closer “Lucky Tune” by ANNA offers an equally catchy, upbeat J-Pop number featuring bubble patterns flashing over Lala in various model-like poses. The soundtrack in between ranges from remarkably bland to quite lively depending on the scene, working best with the heavier rock pieces used for some action scenes and the high-energy synthesized number used when things are going comically amiss and least effectively in the lower-key scene-backing tunes.
Sentai Filmworks ' release of the title puts the thirteen episodes on two disks in a regular-sized case in a facing-each-other packaging arrangement which makes each disk convenient to handle – by far the best packing arrangement of any American company currently releasing two-disk cases. The only Extras, as per the recent norm for Sentai, are clean opener and closer, and the former actually suffers for not having the credits included. (It makes some of the zoom shots seem pointless.) The Subtitle Mistake count for this set is at two, both on the second disk and both involving an accidental replacement of the obviously-correct word with a similarly-spelled incorrect word. Also curiously, one of the menus for the first disk features a character who does not appear until a second-disk episode. As per the norm, there is no English dub and the opener and closer are both the Japanese originals, with English credits only at the very end of each episode.
To Love-Ru was definitely not created with a female audience in mind. It is a series squarely aimed at male otaku, and does exactly what it intends to do: deliver a lot of fan service and a good number of effective laughs. That makes any arguments about how lowbrow or derivative it is largely irrelevant.
Grade:
Overall (sub) : B-
Story : C+
Animation : C+
Art : B
Music : B
+ Plentiful quality fan service, sometimes quite funny, opener and closer.
− Depends too heavily on overused genre elements, some jokes fall flat.
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
new anime,
the anime review,
To Love Ru review,
top anime
The Anime Review : Spice and Wolf vol. 1 (novel)
Synopsis:
For centuries Holo the Wisewolf has maintained a pact with village of Pasloe to insure good wheat harvests. As time passed and a new local noble developed more advanced farming techniques, lonely Holo came to feel that her commitment was no longer needed and she was being more used than respected. Taking human form as a teenage girl with wolf ears and tail, she hooks up with Lawrence, a peddler who regularly does business in Pasloe, and accompanies him on a journey as much about companionship for both as it is about providing a convenient means for her to return to her northern birthplace. Along the way she helps the enterprising Lawrence in business deals as repayment, though a complex scheme involving currency devaluation ultimately proves dangerous for them both. As their association grows, Lawrence starts to realize that there may, in fact, be something more important than profit. When a spice-transporting merchant and a wolf come together, things are never dull.
Review:
Typically when dealing with novels on which anime series are based, the release of the anime version in the United States far precedes the release of the original novel(s) and generally only happens if the anime was at least modestly successful; although those novel releases may hope to get broader exposure, they are really depending heavily on anime fans for their sales. That philosophy seems to be changing, though, and Spice and Wolf's case is evidence of that. Its American release date actually came a week before its anime version release, and other aspects of its release (yes, the cover) also suggest that it is intended to appeal to a broader audience up front rather than depend on the anime. Either that, or it hopes to capitalize on the anime's popularity the moment it hits the market rather than years after the fact. Either way, if it was done intentionally then it is an interesting experiment in timing which bears watching and a further sign that publishing companies importing Japanese novels are doing so in a more timely fashion.
In his Afterword, author Isuna Hasekura talks about aspiring to make a fortune from winning literary awards, and based on the writing seen here, it is obvious why he won one for this effort. His style is smooth and easy to read without coming up short on substance. He never gets bogged down in descriptiveness but still has a sufficient amount of it and never forgets that, in this story, the characters and their interactions matter far more than the events being portrayed; in that sense, his work stands in starkest possible contrast to Hideyuki Kikuchi's Vampire Hunter D novels.
Yes, the events in the story provide the framework, but the relationship which gradually forms here between the mercurial Holo and the more steadfast Lawrence is the novel's greatest strength. The byplay between them is clever and dynamic, constantly adjusting to circumstances and never losing its edge as Lawrence struggles to keep up with Holo in a playful battle of wits. Because of that, we get to follow along as Lawrence gradually realizes that Holo is far from the burden she initially seems to be; she does, in fact, become very important to him because she fills the big hole in his lonely life as a peddler: his lack of companionship. Although the story is told entirely from Lawrence's point of view, Holo's words and deeds also make it clear that the ache of loneliness a mortal could only barely comprehend underlies her words and deeds, so in a way Lawrence is just as valuable a find for her, too. Given where Hasekura shows both characters coming from, it is not at all hard to understand how they become so close and why Lawrence ultimately chooses Holo even over profit and his own safety.
The other advantage of Hasekura's style is that it adapts very easily to anime form. As a result, the first six episodes of the anime version very faithfully replicate the novel, down even to exactly duplicating lines of dialog in most places. In fact, the only substantive change in the anime version is the introduction of the character Cloe, who assumes and expands slightly upon the role of Yarei, Pasloe's wheat trader. In some senses this is an improvement, as the book never did establish a strong enough connection between Lawrence and the village of Pasloe to be satisfying in certain late scenes, although her presence leaves Lawrence seeming less isolated in the anime than he is in the novel. Beyond that, the differences are mostly just points of emphasis. The anime is better able to use Holo's body language to portray her personality, while the novel stresses the loneliness aspect, and how much Lawrence cherishes Holo, a bit more. The anime offers a more convincing conflict of interest for Lawrence in one late scene, while the novel is more effective at portraying the overwhelming nature of Holo's wolf form.
Ayakura's illustrations impress much less. The anime version remained faithful to the style of his character designs but improved on them, as his black-and-white pictures lack sharpness. His color pictures at the front do much better, with his best effort being a rather cute chibi picture of Holo. A great controversy erupted among fans when Yen Press opted to change Ayakura's original cover art (seen at right) with the far more mature and sexy look used on the actual American release cover (seen above). By all appearances this is an attempt to broaden interest beyond just the normal anime/manga crowd, in the hopes that this book could, perhaps, have a shot amongst mainstream fantasy titles. That new cover can certainly attract some attention, all right. . . if stores allow it to be shown somewhere other than just in the manga section, of course.
Yen Press otherwise does an efficient and effective job, producing a translation devoid of the incongruous choices of idioms and slang phrases which too often populate these Japanese imports. It is also free of typos, another problem which commonly plagues translations. Extras are limited to the aforementioned Afterword and the standard color pictures at the beginning.
At 230 pages Spice and Wolf is not a heavy read, and its $10.99 price point puts it higher than most other fantasy novels of comparable length. The size of this paperback release and its color artwork balance that out a bit, though, and it is a good foundation novel for a series which skews a bit older than normal lite novel fare. It offers only a little more insight for those who have seen the TV series, while those who read the novel first will doubtless find themselves wanting to see it in animation.
Grade:
Overall : A-
Story : A-
Art : B-
+ Strong focus on developing its central character relationship, solid writing and English production.
− Price is on the high side given the page count.
For centuries Holo the Wisewolf has maintained a pact with village of Pasloe to insure good wheat harvests. As time passed and a new local noble developed more advanced farming techniques, lonely Holo came to feel that her commitment was no longer needed and she was being more used than respected. Taking human form as a teenage girl with wolf ears and tail, she hooks up with Lawrence, a peddler who regularly does business in Pasloe, and accompanies him on a journey as much about companionship for both as it is about providing a convenient means for her to return to her northern birthplace. Along the way she helps the enterprising Lawrence in business deals as repayment, though a complex scheme involving currency devaluation ultimately proves dangerous for them both. As their association grows, Lawrence starts to realize that there may, in fact, be something more important than profit. When a spice-transporting merchant and a wolf come together, things are never dull.
Review:
Typically when dealing with novels on which anime series are based, the release of the anime version in the United States far precedes the release of the original novel(s) and generally only happens if the anime was at least modestly successful; although those novel releases may hope to get broader exposure, they are really depending heavily on anime fans for their sales. That philosophy seems to be changing, though, and Spice and Wolf's case is evidence of that. Its American release date actually came a week before its anime version release, and other aspects of its release (yes, the cover) also suggest that it is intended to appeal to a broader audience up front rather than depend on the anime. Either that, or it hopes to capitalize on the anime's popularity the moment it hits the market rather than years after the fact. Either way, if it was done intentionally then it is an interesting experiment in timing which bears watching and a further sign that publishing companies importing Japanese novels are doing so in a more timely fashion.
In his Afterword, author Isuna Hasekura talks about aspiring to make a fortune from winning literary awards, and based on the writing seen here, it is obvious why he won one for this effort. His style is smooth and easy to read without coming up short on substance. He never gets bogged down in descriptiveness but still has a sufficient amount of it and never forgets that, in this story, the characters and their interactions matter far more than the events being portrayed; in that sense, his work stands in starkest possible contrast to Hideyuki Kikuchi's Vampire Hunter D novels.
Yes, the events in the story provide the framework, but the relationship which gradually forms here between the mercurial Holo and the more steadfast Lawrence is the novel's greatest strength. The byplay between them is clever and dynamic, constantly adjusting to circumstances and never losing its edge as Lawrence struggles to keep up with Holo in a playful battle of wits. Because of that, we get to follow along as Lawrence gradually realizes that Holo is far from the burden she initially seems to be; she does, in fact, become very important to him because she fills the big hole in his lonely life as a peddler: his lack of companionship. Although the story is told entirely from Lawrence's point of view, Holo's words and deeds also make it clear that the ache of loneliness a mortal could only barely comprehend underlies her words and deeds, so in a way Lawrence is just as valuable a find for her, too. Given where Hasekura shows both characters coming from, it is not at all hard to understand how they become so close and why Lawrence ultimately chooses Holo even over profit and his own safety.
The other advantage of Hasekura's style is that it adapts very easily to anime form. As a result, the first six episodes of the anime version very faithfully replicate the novel, down even to exactly duplicating lines of dialog in most places. In fact, the only substantive change in the anime version is the introduction of the character Cloe, who assumes and expands slightly upon the role of Yarei, Pasloe's wheat trader. In some senses this is an improvement, as the book never did establish a strong enough connection between Lawrence and the village of Pasloe to be satisfying in certain late scenes, although her presence leaves Lawrence seeming less isolated in the anime than he is in the novel. Beyond that, the differences are mostly just points of emphasis. The anime is better able to use Holo's body language to portray her personality, while the novel stresses the loneliness aspect, and how much Lawrence cherishes Holo, a bit more. The anime offers a more convincing conflict of interest for Lawrence in one late scene, while the novel is more effective at portraying the overwhelming nature of Holo's wolf form.
Ayakura's illustrations impress much less. The anime version remained faithful to the style of his character designs but improved on them, as his black-and-white pictures lack sharpness. His color pictures at the front do much better, with his best effort being a rather cute chibi picture of Holo. A great controversy erupted among fans when Yen Press opted to change Ayakura's original cover art (seen at right) with the far more mature and sexy look used on the actual American release cover (seen above). By all appearances this is an attempt to broaden interest beyond just the normal anime/manga crowd, in the hopes that this book could, perhaps, have a shot amongst mainstream fantasy titles. That new cover can certainly attract some attention, all right. . . if stores allow it to be shown somewhere other than just in the manga section, of course.
Yen Press otherwise does an efficient and effective job, producing a translation devoid of the incongruous choices of idioms and slang phrases which too often populate these Japanese imports. It is also free of typos, another problem which commonly plagues translations. Extras are limited to the aforementioned Afterword and the standard color pictures at the beginning.
At 230 pages Spice and Wolf is not a heavy read, and its $10.99 price point puts it higher than most other fantasy novels of comparable length. The size of this paperback release and its color artwork balance that out a bit, though, and it is a good foundation novel for a series which skews a bit older than normal lite novel fare. It offers only a little more insight for those who have seen the TV series, while those who read the novel first will doubtless find themselves wanting to see it in animation.
Grade:
Overall : A-
Story : A-
Art : B-
+ Strong focus on developing its central character relationship, solid writing and English production.
− Price is on the high side given the page count.
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
new anime,
Spice and Wolf review,
the anime review,
top anime
The Anime Review : Slayers Revolution Episodes 1-4 Streaming (dub)
Synopsis:
Having run out of land bandits to abuse for cash, Lina Inverse turns her ill temper and massive magical powers (and even more massive greed) on bandits of the water-trotting variety. While out pounding the bejeezus out of pirates, she and loyal but now swordless sidekick Gourry Gabriev are accosted by Inspector Wizer, a policeman of sorts whose name and shrewd look belie a brain of purest mush. It turns out that Lina is wanted for the crime of being Lina (a crime that even her most devoted friends agree is quite heinous) and Wizer is intent on bringing her in. Lina being Lina, as the warrant states, she proceeds to blow the hell out of his kingdom. Until she discovers that she's being framed for the crimes of someone else—a furry little...something with magical powers to rival hers—and directs her decidedly unhealthy attentions towards the fuzzy interloper.
Review:
If there is such a thing as classic stupidity, Slayers is it. A longtime staple of the mid-90s anime boom, it garnered a considerable following while remaining unremittingly and unrepentantly brainless. Which was, in large part, why it was fantastic fun. And still is. After a decade of moldering in the tomb o' has-been anime, the franchise's creators have deemed the silly beast worthy of resurrection. If the decision smacks of pointless nostalgia-wallowing, well, just remember: there was never any point to begin with.
Like any resurrected corpse, Slayers Revolution shuffles along some at first. You can almost hear it mumbling "brains..." as it clumsily reacquaints us with its cast via stand-and-deliver introductory speeches, and you can clearly feel it lurching, stiff with retreating death, as it wastes precious time spoofing Jack Sparrow and smiling indulgently as its main characters run through their signature shtick. It continues stumbling right through the introduction of smart-talking, nauseatingly cute magical rabbit-thing Pokota. And then almost immediately redeems itself by beating the snot out of him. It isn't long thereafter that the series regains its fleet-footed irreverence, and it never once looks back. Sight-gags both familiar (the series' very peculiar mermaids) and brand-new (Lina punching Wizer into the sky while cuffed to his wrist) fly fast and thick, and much fun is had with Lina and co.'s decidedly un-heroic behavior as the series runs through several exceedingly frivolous stories about petnapping and shoddy Lina-made "tanks." Yes it's repetitive, yes it's meandering, and yes you can actually feel it killing your brain cells, but it's also hilarious—particularly if you have a soft spot for any of the characters—and it doesn't try to be anything it's not. And that excuses a lot. Plus, under all those breast jokes there is a plot, albeit a well-disguised and likely uninteresting one.
As exactingly as the series replicates its old charms, so too does it replicate its old look—shiny CGI veneer aside. Which is to say that it looks really cheap. Animation is poorly controlled and downright ugly at times, character designs constantly shift proportions and facial features, and action is rendered via stills and movements made affordable by constantly MIA backgrounds. And then there's the hair, flapping in the wind like the badly-looped pelts of dead muskrats. In a word: sloppy. The backgrounds by contrast are crisp and vibrant and fantasy-ish, the colors are bright and clean, and the magical displays are genuinely impressive; hinting that perhaps the series' quality-control issues are more intentional than they appear. But even if they aren't, Lina and Amelia's major old(ish)-school cuteness is recompense enough.
Backgrounds aren't the only things appropriately fantasy-ish, there's also Osamu Tezuka's (no relation) score. When not buried beneath bickering leads and exploding towns, it hits a number of fantasy-ish tones: sinister orchestral atmosphere, ascending action instrumentals, that thing that fantasy scores do when they're panning over fantasy landscapes. There's also a lot of dippy comedy music and the occasional musical joke (that "level-up" note it hits when Gourry finishes a meal). Mostly, though, it's just buried. As with Slayers series past, actress Megumi Hayashibara (Lina) bookends each episode with a pair of reasonably solid pop tunes.
To fully avail themselves of the franchise's nostalgia value, Funimation delivers an odd treat for Slayers old-timers: Central Park Media's original dub cast (or as near as can be managed), reprising their roles ten years after the fact. A random act of kindness on the company's part, and one that pays off handsomely. Funimation's dub is a very pleasant surprise. The years have been kind to Lisa Ortiz and her cast-mates. Each easily thrashes their previous performance, and ADR directors Michael Sinterniklaas and Marc Diraison (the guys behind Right Stuf's superb Ninja Nonsense dub) provide a steady and, when the mood takes them, inventive guiding hand, delivering a smooth English version that communicates with ease the series' light charm.
Nostalgia is a powerful thing, and perhaps the only thing separating this from its many contemporary imitators. Though to know that, you'd have to be free of its steely grip, which I'm not. As it stands this is as fine an opportunity to revisit your old Slayers friends as you'll likely find. So say hi, grab some grub and sit back and enjoy wasting your life away with the whole crew of fantasy fightin' failures. There's twenty some odd episodes to come, and with luck they'll be as mindlessly amusing as the seventy some odd that came before.
Grade:
Overall (dub) : B
Story : C
Animation : C-
Art : C+
Music : C+
+ As fun as Slayers ever was.
− As lazy and frivolous as it ever was.
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
new anime,
Slayers Revolution review,
the anime review,
top anime
The Anime Review : Rin : Daughters of Mnemosyne DVD
Synopsis:
Rin is a curvaceous small-time detective with a dark secret; she's an immortal, carrying a "Time Fruit" from the ever-present Yggdrasil, the tree of life. She can take a whole lot of physical punishment (and can easily regenerate her body parts), which is a good thing, because when Apos, a godlike creature with a sadistic streak shows up and wants to drink her memories like so much Gatorade, the battle's on!
Review:
RIN ~Daughters of Mnemosyne~ was originally created as an “anniversary project” for the Japanese cable channel AT-X, which is most known among anime fans for being the boob-friendly network that airs uncensored versions of stuff like Queen's Blade and Charger Girl Ju-den-chan late at night. In a sense, they're kinda like Japan's version of Cinemax, which is famous (or infamous, rather) for running low-budget softcore porn, usually gussied up in sci-fi or thriller genre trappings (and with hilarious titles like Alien Sex Invasion or Detective Lust or something like that) in the wee hours of the morning.
So it stands to reason that Mnemosyne feels exactly like one of those silly “Skinemax” movies, with the requisite amounts of violence, kinky sex and violent kinky sex piled on so you're aware that what you're watching is totally edgy anime for adults. Surprisingly, and perhaps in spite of all that, Mnemosyne isn't really a bad show, provided you know what you're getting in to and don't take any of it very seriously for even a second.
Rin, overall, is a little complex but not difficult to decipher; there's this big ethereal magic tree (Yggdrasil, marking the 10,000th time the legendary Norse ‘tree of life’ has been referenced in an anime) that sheds these things called “Time Fruits” that float down to the general populace. When one infects a woman, she becomes an immortal who can withstand a ridiculous amount of physical damage. When one infects a man, he becomes a rageful superpowered winged beast (nicknamed “angels”). Notably the immortal women can't help but desperately want to have sex with the angels, who devour them during the act. Rin, a green-haired, fiercely independent woman with serious karate skills who runs a small-time detective agency, is one such immortal. Although her stated business is finding lost cats and tracking down stolen items, pretty much every case she takes winds up connecting to her mysterious (and sexy!) past in some fashion, and usually involves a lot of violence and expository dialogue that explains the show's weird plot. The chief villain is a smug kid named Apos who seems to wander between “immortal” and “angel”, obviously knows everything there is to know about this strange world, really enjoys tormenting immoral girls in bondage and, naturally, must have Rin for himself!
Story-wise, Mnemosyne feels like halfway-decent dark erotica if it were written by someone in their early 20's who's played a whole lot of “adult” tabletop roleplaying games. There are some pretty unique story ideas in here and some fun pseudo-religious imagery; while it's difficult to honestly care about any of these characters, the show walks the line between “confusing” and “compelling” just well enough to keep you watching and wondering. By the final episodes, the show gets really bogged down with exposition and it feels like you're just watching the characters explain what the hell is going on while raping and eating eachother, but hey, it's never boring, and it remains interesting until the very end.
The show absolutely has a preoccupation with violent sex and torture, and presumably, that's the selling point here. It's all very EDGY – meaning you're going to see a lot of sexual mutilation and rape and people getting sliced up while naked and all that. To be frank, the shock value is pretty much over by the end of the first episode (which features such pleasantries as involuntary nipple piercing), once you realize they're going to just go as far as they can with the bloody sex angle. Simply put, they're trying too hard and there's just so much of it (especially in the series' Grand Guignol final episode) that you wind up laughing and rolling your eyes at each new atrocity rather than having your mind blown on the train to edge-ville. Which is for the best, really; there's so much ludicrous violence and sex in this thing that if it actually did have an impact on the viewer or felt like anything more than the screenwriters showing off just how “adult” they can be, the result would just be exhausting and unpleasant. As it is, the fact that it's nearly impossible to take Mnemosyne seriously is a mark in the show's favor and adds to the whole trashy appeal. It's guilty late-night cable entertainment through and through.
The production values are pretty good, and it looks like they had a nice OVA-sized budget to make this thing happen. The animation is uniformly very fluid, the characters – who have very distinctive designs and aren't just generic girls with neon hair – stay on-model, and the fight scenes are generally very well done. The show's visuals manage a strange consistency even when they're fluctuating wildly between standard modern-day Tokyo landscapes and End of Evangelion-esque sex-apocalypse theatrics, which is a considerable feat of design; it'd have been easy to make this show feel like it's two completely different series mashed into one, but they manage to avoid that pitfall. The lone exception to the show's overall high quality is the score, which sounds suspiciously like it was ripped from a 1990s PC game.
Funimation 's dub is about what you'd expect from them at this point: a pretty high quality, mostly-rewritten-for-the-better affair that makes the dialogue flow a lot more naturally in English. There's a bit more swearing than there is in the Japanese track (at least according to the subtitles), but that's sort of par for the course for a show like this. Colleen Clinkenbeard
RIN ~Daughters of Mnemosyne~ is yet another in a long line of “adult” anime series where the word “adult” doesn't necessarily mean “mature”, rather simply that the series is completely inappropriate for kids. However, as hilariously extreme as Mnemosyne gets, it still somehow manages to avoid that creeping juvenile feeling that infected previous attempts at this genre (Speed Grapher, that means you). It is by no means a series to be taken seriously and should probably be watched one episode at a time rather than shotgunning the box set in a single sitting (one can only take so much of this at a time), but if you're looking for fun, weird, entertaining sleaze without a hint of irony or cutesiness, this is it.
Just keep the volume down so your neighbors can't hear all the moaning and stabbing.
Grade:
Overall : B-
Overall (dub) : B
Overall (sub) : B-
Story : C
Animation : A
Art : A
Music : C
+ Trashy fun, unique storyline, great dub, nice animation.
− Really, really, really violent and nasty; expository dialogue runneth over.
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
new anime,
rin daughter of mnemosyne review,
the anime review,
top anime
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




