What on Earth could these characters possibly be doing in the same place? Telltale's next game brings them all together!
2010/08/29
Game Review Video : Exclusive Debut Teaser
Game Review Video : Exclusive Debut Teaser
What on Earth could these characters possibly be doing in the same place? Telltale's next game brings them all together!
What on Earth could these characters possibly be doing in the same place? Telltale's next game brings them all together!
The Anime Review : Hikaru no Go 18
Synopsis:
Diverging away from the main storyline, this volume focuses on six side stories about six of the main characters: Akira Toya, Tetsuo Kaga, Asumi Nase, Yuki Mitani, Atsushi Kurata and Fujiwara-no-Sai. Akira and Mitani's stories center on what they're doing right before they meet Hikaru; Kaga and Asumi's stories expand upon what they're currently up to; Kurata's story pays a visit to the Go player before he first starts playing the game; and Sai's story follows him and a younger Hikaru on a little misadventure in an arts and pottery shop.
Review:
It's not uncommon for series, especially longer ones, to take a bit of a break from the main storyline to delve into chapters about other popular characters in order to flesh them out, tell a story that the mangaka or writer really wanted to tell but couldn't because it didn't fit anywhere else, or take a break from a story that may be getting too stressful or intense. Considering a major part of the main storyline was just wrapped up at the end of volume 17, this volume is the perfect time to sing these untold tales, especially since several are about characters who haven't appeared in the manga recently.
Unfortunately, what could have been six unique glimpses into these characters' lives instead ends up being a collection of mostly uninteresting stories that will leave even die-hard fans of the characters disappointed.
Akira Toya's story travels back in time to just before he meets his soon-to-be rival and shows him playing two minor characters, but aside from a sweet little moment between Akira and his father, the entire chapter lacks any real meaning and doesn't develop Akira beyond what we've already known about him since the beginning of the series. The most notable thing about this chapter is the art. Fans of little Akira will have plenty of cute and serious faces to gush over, but more importantly, comparing Akira at the beginning of the series to his youthful return really emphasizes how Takeshi Obata's lines and details have improved over the course of the series.
Tetsuo Kaga's story steps back into the present as he returns to Haze Middle School to play some Shogi, but instead finds himself detoured to help the one remaining student in the Go club: Hitoshi Koike. Even though this story is supposed to be about Kaga, more time is spent focusing on Koike, whose easily excitable but wholly uninteresting personality makes it hard for the reader to root for this underdog.
After two dull chapters, it's surprising to discover that Asumi Nase's story is actually interesting. Hikaru no Go has never hidden the fact that women aren't a big part of the Go world, but it's never touched upon the way those who don't play Go view female professional players. In this chapter, we actually get to see a unique side of Asumi, who is more comfortable around shady adults than she is a boy of her own age. The irony is that the adults are impressed with her skill and actually want to spend more time with her, yet her date, the only one her own age, is the one most intimidated by her. In the end, she realizes it's easier to struggle forward in the Go world as a professional female player than it is to be a “normal” 16-year-old girl.
The next chapter on Yuki Mitani suffers from the same weakness as Akira's story does – namely, the flashback doesn't reveal anything we didn't already know about the character – and flounders even more when it wastes entire pages on Mr. Shu and Mr. Dake planning to teach Mitani a lesson.
Interestingly enough, it's Atsushi Kurata's tale that stands out the most. Focusing on the relationship between a young Kurata and an English teacher-in-training, the chapter explores Kurata's knack for studying information about horse racers and then using these facts to guess the winner of a race. However, no amount of information can predict the unexpected, and that's where Kurata's intuition comes into play. At the end, a correlation is drawn between racing horses and playing Go: that is, no matter how much information or strategy you have, it's intuition that makes the difference between a good player and a great one.
The volume tries to wrap up on a high note with the return of Sai, everyone's favorite curious and energetic ball of ethereal fluff, but trips over its own feet as it devolves into a chaotic mess in a pottery shop with yet another crooked seller trying to pawn fake merchandise off as the real deal to unsuspecting customers. The “trick” to Keicho's vase is a unique twist that includes some of the most beautiful drawings in the entire volume, but it's still not enough to save Sai's story from crumbling into a boring pile of rubble.
Volume 18, even for its few shining moments, just doesn't bring much to the table. Very little Go is played, even less is accomplished in the way of character development, and unless you're the type who's determined to read everything related to Hikaru no Go, your collection will not suffer if you decide to leave this one out.
Grade:
Overall : C-
Story : D
Art : B+ + Skillful artwork shows how the artist has grown, and Asumi and Kurata's stories are somewhat interesting.
− Almost zero character development and annoying side characters drag the entire volume down.
Diverging away from the main storyline, this volume focuses on six side stories about six of the main characters: Akira Toya, Tetsuo Kaga, Asumi Nase, Yuki Mitani, Atsushi Kurata and Fujiwara-no-Sai. Akira and Mitani's stories center on what they're doing right before they meet Hikaru; Kaga and Asumi's stories expand upon what they're currently up to; Kurata's story pays a visit to the Go player before he first starts playing the game; and Sai's story follows him and a younger Hikaru on a little misadventure in an arts and pottery shop.
Review:
It's not uncommon for series, especially longer ones, to take a bit of a break from the main storyline to delve into chapters about other popular characters in order to flesh them out, tell a story that the mangaka or writer really wanted to tell but couldn't because it didn't fit anywhere else, or take a break from a story that may be getting too stressful or intense. Considering a major part of the main storyline was just wrapped up at the end of volume 17, this volume is the perfect time to sing these untold tales, especially since several are about characters who haven't appeared in the manga recently.
Unfortunately, what could have been six unique glimpses into these characters' lives instead ends up being a collection of mostly uninteresting stories that will leave even die-hard fans of the characters disappointed.
Akira Toya's story travels back in time to just before he meets his soon-to-be rival and shows him playing two minor characters, but aside from a sweet little moment between Akira and his father, the entire chapter lacks any real meaning and doesn't develop Akira beyond what we've already known about him since the beginning of the series. The most notable thing about this chapter is the art. Fans of little Akira will have plenty of cute and serious faces to gush over, but more importantly, comparing Akira at the beginning of the series to his youthful return really emphasizes how Takeshi Obata's lines and details have improved over the course of the series.
Tetsuo Kaga's story steps back into the present as he returns to Haze Middle School to play some Shogi, but instead finds himself detoured to help the one remaining student in the Go club: Hitoshi Koike. Even though this story is supposed to be about Kaga, more time is spent focusing on Koike, whose easily excitable but wholly uninteresting personality makes it hard for the reader to root for this underdog.
After two dull chapters, it's surprising to discover that Asumi Nase's story is actually interesting. Hikaru no Go has never hidden the fact that women aren't a big part of the Go world, but it's never touched upon the way those who don't play Go view female professional players. In this chapter, we actually get to see a unique side of Asumi, who is more comfortable around shady adults than she is a boy of her own age. The irony is that the adults are impressed with her skill and actually want to spend more time with her, yet her date, the only one her own age, is the one most intimidated by her. In the end, she realizes it's easier to struggle forward in the Go world as a professional female player than it is to be a “normal” 16-year-old girl.
The next chapter on Yuki Mitani suffers from the same weakness as Akira's story does – namely, the flashback doesn't reveal anything we didn't already know about the character – and flounders even more when it wastes entire pages on Mr. Shu and Mr. Dake planning to teach Mitani a lesson.
Interestingly enough, it's Atsushi Kurata's tale that stands out the most. Focusing on the relationship between a young Kurata and an English teacher-in-training, the chapter explores Kurata's knack for studying information about horse racers and then using these facts to guess the winner of a race. However, no amount of information can predict the unexpected, and that's where Kurata's intuition comes into play. At the end, a correlation is drawn between racing horses and playing Go: that is, no matter how much information or strategy you have, it's intuition that makes the difference between a good player and a great one.
The volume tries to wrap up on a high note with the return of Sai, everyone's favorite curious and energetic ball of ethereal fluff, but trips over its own feet as it devolves into a chaotic mess in a pottery shop with yet another crooked seller trying to pawn fake merchandise off as the real deal to unsuspecting customers. The “trick” to Keicho's vase is a unique twist that includes some of the most beautiful drawings in the entire volume, but it's still not enough to save Sai's story from crumbling into a boring pile of rubble.
Volume 18, even for its few shining moments, just doesn't bring much to the table. Very little Go is played, even less is accomplished in the way of character development, and unless you're the type who's determined to read everything related to Hikaru no Go, your collection will not suffer if you decide to leave this one out.
Grade:
Overall : C-
Story : D
Art : B+ + Skillful artwork shows how the artist has grown, and Asumi and Kurata's stories are somewhat interesting.
− Almost zero character development and annoying side characters drag the entire volume down.
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
Hikaru no Go 18 review,
new anime,
the anime review,
top anime
The Anime Review : Hanasakeru Seishonen Episodes 1-6 Streaming
Synopsis:
After being raised on a remote island by order of her eccentric father, 14-year old Kajika Burnsworth is finally being called back home. She has trouble adjusting to the outside world and relies on her childhood friend-turned-bodyguard Lee-Leng to support her on the trip to meet her father, who promises to reveal his plans for her destiny on one condition. She must play a "marriage game" wherein he has selected three men of high standing he will accept as future husbands for her. She must guess who these suitors are and then make her marriage selection, with Lee-Leng as her escort, if she wants to accept the blessing of her father and begin her life as a young woman among the elite.
Review:
There's no disguising the odor: Hanasakeru Seishōnen (Flowering Youth) smells a lot like chauvinism. A naïve young girl must find a rich, older man to marry in order to discover her life's meaning…as dictated by her father? More than being just a faux pas, it's an extremely insulting idea. Well, it is in theory. In practice, the “tender flower” Kajika seems to be the only one in control, and that's what makes it work. Her tenacity and spunk attracts and heals others and makes her the center of the reverse harem at hand.
Kajika was raised by an old Creole priestess in the Caribbean with only a large white leopard (must be imported?) and her stoic bodyguard for companionship. As such, she's developed some odd ideas about life and social norms and doesn't hesitate to confront brutish men regardless of their size or power or throw herself into uncomfortable situations to make a new friend. If it weren't for the aforementioned stoic bodyguard, Kajika would not fare well in the big city, but her joie de vivre is hopelessly contagious even under the shield of her imperious escort, Lee-leng. The balance between their personalities and dependence on each other makes the show work, and most times, they're the only people in the world who understand one another. At the same time, they argue frequently, as Lee-leng is overly protective and Kajika overly impetuous. Really, reverse harem aside, this bodyguard appears to be the prime love interest for Kajika…except that Lee-leng can never be one of the three choices. It's something that pains him to acknowledge, but he keeps his feelings to himself.
On that note, the series is pleasantly unusual in its presentation of the suitors. Rather than throwing the sparkling idols right in our faces in the first episode, the series spends a solid three episodes on the first of these, Eugene, and has only begun to introduce the second, Rumaty, by the sixth episode. Like Lee-leng, Eugene is far from being the perfect man, having driven several previous girlfriends to suicide without remorse. Kajika is instantly drawn to him, however, because of his uncanny resemblance to her deceased leopard friend Mustafa, who she is sure has reincarnated to dwell inside Eugene. Rather than leading to an angst-filled romance, this leads to more dangerous conflicts as Eugene has his own dark plans to see to and doesn't mind playing up the ruse that he could be “Mustafa” to humor a rich young beauty. Needless to say, Lee-leng will do anything to tear her away from this disturbed suitor and within two episodes, the story has taken a darker and tenser turn than some shojo reach in their final arcs.
Foreign prince Rumaty is still fairly mysterious, but clearly a wild child quite different from Eugene, and equally disdained by Lee-leng and adored by Kajika. With such a well-balanced cast of characters and a remarkably steady tone that never lances into super-deformed mania or strained melodrama, there's a lot of potential for a great romance here.
Tragically, all that potential could be boiled down nicely on paper, but drifts by devoid of enthusiasm onscreen. From its passable character models to its tired, plinking music, the series does not seek to impress on any aesthetic level. Good direction could have compensated for the production setbacks, but this too is uninspired, as nearly every shot is composed of talking heads backed by unimpressive seiyuu performances. It's hard to even comment on the animation because unless we're talking mouth flaps, it's barely present until a mild action scene in episode 6. Despite visiting at least four famous cities over the course of six episodes, there's never an attempt to drink in any atmosphere. Despite possessing unique, complex characters, every scene of the series is taken up with them explaining their every thought aloud rather than letting the audience discover the characters through their actions. Hanasakeru Seishōnen might as well have been a radio drama for the complete lack of attention paid to its visuals, and this is especially shocking in light of the fact that director Chiaki Kon's previous works, the Higurashi franchise, thrived on snappy editing and disconcerting camera angles. As previously mentioned, it does not help that the dialogue is dreadfully rife with exposition and blunt internal monologues fill the spaces when no one is speaking aloud.
The heart of the anime is strong and full of promise, particularly for shojo, a genre always gasping for good material in a dearth of saccharine and immature garbage. There is an engaging story with great characters hiding here, so it's unfortunate that the flower the creators have planted has no fragrance or panache whatsoever despite these good elements. The theme songs are the lone exception to this, with passionate Kelly Clarkson-style guitar ballads that support the series well, but they aren't enough to make anyone stick around for the blah-fest to follow. One can only hope it hasn't fully bloomed yet, but if the production quality and writing of the series remain as constant as its tone, there's no sense in holding your breath waiting. Good ideas are a dime a dozen, and Hanasakeru's various novelties are so far left floundering in a sea of horribly bland presentation.
Grade:
Overall (sub) : C
Story : B-
Animation : C
Art : C+
Music : C+
+ Fertile premise, diverse and complementary love interests
− Expositional monologuing, bland and tepid throughout
After being raised on a remote island by order of her eccentric father, 14-year old Kajika Burnsworth is finally being called back home. She has trouble adjusting to the outside world and relies on her childhood friend-turned-bodyguard Lee-Leng to support her on the trip to meet her father, who promises to reveal his plans for her destiny on one condition. She must play a "marriage game" wherein he has selected three men of high standing he will accept as future husbands for her. She must guess who these suitors are and then make her marriage selection, with Lee-Leng as her escort, if she wants to accept the blessing of her father and begin her life as a young woman among the elite.
Review:
There's no disguising the odor: Hanasakeru Seishōnen (Flowering Youth) smells a lot like chauvinism. A naïve young girl must find a rich, older man to marry in order to discover her life's meaning…as dictated by her father? More than being just a faux pas, it's an extremely insulting idea. Well, it is in theory. In practice, the “tender flower” Kajika seems to be the only one in control, and that's what makes it work. Her tenacity and spunk attracts and heals others and makes her the center of the reverse harem at hand.
Kajika was raised by an old Creole priestess in the Caribbean with only a large white leopard (must be imported?) and her stoic bodyguard for companionship. As such, she's developed some odd ideas about life and social norms and doesn't hesitate to confront brutish men regardless of their size or power or throw herself into uncomfortable situations to make a new friend. If it weren't for the aforementioned stoic bodyguard, Kajika would not fare well in the big city, but her joie de vivre is hopelessly contagious even under the shield of her imperious escort, Lee-leng. The balance between their personalities and dependence on each other makes the show work, and most times, they're the only people in the world who understand one another. At the same time, they argue frequently, as Lee-leng is overly protective and Kajika overly impetuous. Really, reverse harem aside, this bodyguard appears to be the prime love interest for Kajika…except that Lee-leng can never be one of the three choices. It's something that pains him to acknowledge, but he keeps his feelings to himself.
On that note, the series is pleasantly unusual in its presentation of the suitors. Rather than throwing the sparkling idols right in our faces in the first episode, the series spends a solid three episodes on the first of these, Eugene, and has only begun to introduce the second, Rumaty, by the sixth episode. Like Lee-leng, Eugene is far from being the perfect man, having driven several previous girlfriends to suicide without remorse. Kajika is instantly drawn to him, however, because of his uncanny resemblance to her deceased leopard friend Mustafa, who she is sure has reincarnated to dwell inside Eugene. Rather than leading to an angst-filled romance, this leads to more dangerous conflicts as Eugene has his own dark plans to see to and doesn't mind playing up the ruse that he could be “Mustafa” to humor a rich young beauty. Needless to say, Lee-leng will do anything to tear her away from this disturbed suitor and within two episodes, the story has taken a darker and tenser turn than some shojo reach in their final arcs.
Foreign prince Rumaty is still fairly mysterious, but clearly a wild child quite different from Eugene, and equally disdained by Lee-leng and adored by Kajika. With such a well-balanced cast of characters and a remarkably steady tone that never lances into super-deformed mania or strained melodrama, there's a lot of potential for a great romance here.
Tragically, all that potential could be boiled down nicely on paper, but drifts by devoid of enthusiasm onscreen. From its passable character models to its tired, plinking music, the series does not seek to impress on any aesthetic level. Good direction could have compensated for the production setbacks, but this too is uninspired, as nearly every shot is composed of talking heads backed by unimpressive seiyuu performances. It's hard to even comment on the animation because unless we're talking mouth flaps, it's barely present until a mild action scene in episode 6. Despite visiting at least four famous cities over the course of six episodes, there's never an attempt to drink in any atmosphere. Despite possessing unique, complex characters, every scene of the series is taken up with them explaining their every thought aloud rather than letting the audience discover the characters through their actions. Hanasakeru Seishōnen might as well have been a radio drama for the complete lack of attention paid to its visuals, and this is especially shocking in light of the fact that director Chiaki Kon's previous works, the Higurashi franchise, thrived on snappy editing and disconcerting camera angles. As previously mentioned, it does not help that the dialogue is dreadfully rife with exposition and blunt internal monologues fill the spaces when no one is speaking aloud.
The heart of the anime is strong and full of promise, particularly for shojo, a genre always gasping for good material in a dearth of saccharine and immature garbage. There is an engaging story with great characters hiding here, so it's unfortunate that the flower the creators have planted has no fragrance or panache whatsoever despite these good elements. The theme songs are the lone exception to this, with passionate Kelly Clarkson-style guitar ballads that support the series well, but they aren't enough to make anyone stick around for the blah-fest to follow. One can only hope it hasn't fully bloomed yet, but if the production quality and writing of the series remain as constant as its tone, there's no sense in holding your breath waiting. Good ideas are a dime a dozen, and Hanasakeru's various novelties are so far left floundering in a sea of horribly bland presentation.
Grade:
Overall (sub) : C
Story : B-
Animation : C
Art : C+
Music : C+
+ Fertile premise, diverse and complementary love interests
− Expositional monologuing, bland and tepid throughout
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
Hanasakeru Seishonen review,
new anime,
the anime review,
top anime
The Anime Review : Gunslinger Girl OVA DVD
Synopsis:
After the bridge bombing fiasco has settled, it's business as usual for the Social Welfare Agency, and the Rico-Jean fratello are off to Venice to take down a Mafioso and clean out a den of terrorists. After the dust settles, Guise arranges for a vacation to his family's old sea cottage, inviting Henrietta, Jean, and Rico to come along. The girls find respite in the exquisite grandeur of Sicily, but Jean only finds himself haunted by visions of the past. Meanwhile, Triela stays at the dorms and reminisces with Claes about what they've all gone through.
Review:
It's been stated many times that Gunslinger Girl's second season, Il Teatrino, is a disappointing step backwards from where the series had started in artistry and storytelling. However, if there was one thing Il Teatrino possessed that its predecessor did not, it was an engaging plot, full of political intrigue, moral ambiguity, and poignant climaxes to character arcs that had been left hanging from the first season. The conclusion to Il Teatrino was satisfying enough that an OVA doesn't seem terribly necessary, so what do these final two episodes offer?
Sadly, not much of anything. The first episode, The Light of Venice, the Darkness of the Heart, is a complete throwaway as Jean and Rico track down more terrorists hiding out in Italy's famous tourist city where gondolas abound. The terrorist threat itself is not very well explained and rapidly disposed of, and while Rico is given room to expose her inner anxieties, it's nothing we haven't seen before in better episodes of the series. The second episode, Fantasma, appears to be just as trivial but takes an interesting turn halfway through. Throughout two seasons of Gunslinger Girl, only one lead character has never been sufficiently explored: Jean. His bitter mistreatment of Rico has never been explained to even the slightest degree, but when faced with a ghostly figure he's been trying to forget, it all becomes clear. The events that made Guise and Jean react so very differently to their fratello are left largely vague, but their emotional response to the past tragedy is communicated very well in this one key scene. Despite being entrenched in unimpressive filler, Jean's revelation of character after being such a cold fish for 26 episodes is quite rewarding.
Rewarding though it may be, it only opens the door for the series to be continued rather than tying up the second season, which was already succinctly tied up and simply gets revisited during Triela's short scenes in the OVA. This DVD is largely forgettable, for completionists only, but will certainly satisfy fans who wanted to see more of Guise and Jean's souls laid bare…along with their chests in the beach scenes. At the very least, it's a harmless excursion for the story.
The art and animation are congruous with all of Il Teatrino, which is to say it doesn't look very good. The animation, handled by Artland in place of MADHOUSE who produced the first season, is at least acceptable for an action series. Still, it's loaded with speed lines and jerky transitions, while the conversation-heavy scenes are merely boring and minimalistic, so it doesn't do the series any favors either. Either way, there isn't much action in this OVA to pick on. The real detriment to the series' visuals is the revised art style of Il Teatrino, a creation entirely different from the first season of Gunslinger Girl. (There's also a new voice cast if you're watching in Japanese.)
At best, the new character designs are boring. The handlers' angular faces and smaller eyes make them look more like Ken dolls than conflicted adult characters. At worst, the new designs are garish and unattractive as most of the damage is done to the gunslinging girls. The generic moe-fied faces take all the subtlety out of the girls' expressions, and make the series' focus on them as victimized little girls a moot point now that they look more like plastic figurines. Visually, the series seems burdened with a malaise of flatness. The characters, the backgrounds, and the lighting are bland and lacking in any dimension or expressiveness.
The music is reminiscent of Kou Ohtani's score for Il Teatrino but sounds far less refined. Most of the selections are forgettable, and many overused synthesizer pieces are grating rather than charming. Even Claes' theme, an echoey rendition of Scarborough Fair, returns in a simpler incarnation that lacks the beauty of the original. Performances in either language are solid, but due to a lack of good material to run with in the OVA, there isn't much to comment on beyond that. The series' second season voice cast returns in the OVA, while the English version retains its cast from the first season onward with the exception of Hilshire, who is played by J. Michael Tatum replacing Dameon Clarke.
Extras include the clean closers for both episodes (the opening song is not used in the OVA, sadly,) and a myriad of trailers. Also included is a conversation-style interview between the seiyuu for Triela and Hilshire wherein they discuss their experiences working on the show and compete to see who can draw a better picture of Pinocchio. Of course, no one informed Masaya Matsukaze which “Pinocchio” to draw. It's probably more enjoyable than the OVA itself, which possesses none of the beauty and subtlety of the original series, but also lacks the intrigue and excellent writing of Il Teatrino. As such, it doesn't really have anywhere to go.
Grade:
Overall (dub) : C
Overall (sub) : C
Story : C-
Animation : C+
Art : C
Music : C+
+ Satisfying character development for Guise and especially Jean
− Otherwise pointless, for completionists only
After the bridge bombing fiasco has settled, it's business as usual for the Social Welfare Agency, and the Rico-Jean fratello are off to Venice to take down a Mafioso and clean out a den of terrorists. After the dust settles, Guise arranges for a vacation to his family's old sea cottage, inviting Henrietta, Jean, and Rico to come along. The girls find respite in the exquisite grandeur of Sicily, but Jean only finds himself haunted by visions of the past. Meanwhile, Triela stays at the dorms and reminisces with Claes about what they've all gone through.
Review:
It's been stated many times that Gunslinger Girl's second season, Il Teatrino, is a disappointing step backwards from where the series had started in artistry and storytelling. However, if there was one thing Il Teatrino possessed that its predecessor did not, it was an engaging plot, full of political intrigue, moral ambiguity, and poignant climaxes to character arcs that had been left hanging from the first season. The conclusion to Il Teatrino was satisfying enough that an OVA doesn't seem terribly necessary, so what do these final two episodes offer?
Sadly, not much of anything. The first episode, The Light of Venice, the Darkness of the Heart, is a complete throwaway as Jean and Rico track down more terrorists hiding out in Italy's famous tourist city where gondolas abound. The terrorist threat itself is not very well explained and rapidly disposed of, and while Rico is given room to expose her inner anxieties, it's nothing we haven't seen before in better episodes of the series. The second episode, Fantasma, appears to be just as trivial but takes an interesting turn halfway through. Throughout two seasons of Gunslinger Girl, only one lead character has never been sufficiently explored: Jean. His bitter mistreatment of Rico has never been explained to even the slightest degree, but when faced with a ghostly figure he's been trying to forget, it all becomes clear. The events that made Guise and Jean react so very differently to their fratello are left largely vague, but their emotional response to the past tragedy is communicated very well in this one key scene. Despite being entrenched in unimpressive filler, Jean's revelation of character after being such a cold fish for 26 episodes is quite rewarding.
Rewarding though it may be, it only opens the door for the series to be continued rather than tying up the second season, which was already succinctly tied up and simply gets revisited during Triela's short scenes in the OVA. This DVD is largely forgettable, for completionists only, but will certainly satisfy fans who wanted to see more of Guise and Jean's souls laid bare…along with their chests in the beach scenes. At the very least, it's a harmless excursion for the story.
The art and animation are congruous with all of Il Teatrino, which is to say it doesn't look very good. The animation, handled by Artland in place of MADHOUSE who produced the first season, is at least acceptable for an action series. Still, it's loaded with speed lines and jerky transitions, while the conversation-heavy scenes are merely boring and minimalistic, so it doesn't do the series any favors either. Either way, there isn't much action in this OVA to pick on. The real detriment to the series' visuals is the revised art style of Il Teatrino, a creation entirely different from the first season of Gunslinger Girl. (There's also a new voice cast if you're watching in Japanese.)
At best, the new character designs are boring. The handlers' angular faces and smaller eyes make them look more like Ken dolls than conflicted adult characters. At worst, the new designs are garish and unattractive as most of the damage is done to the gunslinging girls. The generic moe-fied faces take all the subtlety out of the girls' expressions, and make the series' focus on them as victimized little girls a moot point now that they look more like plastic figurines. Visually, the series seems burdened with a malaise of flatness. The characters, the backgrounds, and the lighting are bland and lacking in any dimension or expressiveness.
The music is reminiscent of Kou Ohtani's score for Il Teatrino but sounds far less refined. Most of the selections are forgettable, and many overused synthesizer pieces are grating rather than charming. Even Claes' theme, an echoey rendition of Scarborough Fair, returns in a simpler incarnation that lacks the beauty of the original. Performances in either language are solid, but due to a lack of good material to run with in the OVA, there isn't much to comment on beyond that. The series' second season voice cast returns in the OVA, while the English version retains its cast from the first season onward with the exception of Hilshire, who is played by J. Michael Tatum replacing Dameon Clarke.
Extras include the clean closers for both episodes (the opening song is not used in the OVA, sadly,) and a myriad of trailers. Also included is a conversation-style interview between the seiyuu for Triela and Hilshire wherein they discuss their experiences working on the show and compete to see who can draw a better picture of Pinocchio. Of course, no one informed Masaya Matsukaze which “Pinocchio” to draw. It's probably more enjoyable than the OVA itself, which possesses none of the beauty and subtlety of the original series, but also lacks the intrigue and excellent writing of Il Teatrino. As such, it doesn't really have anywhere to go.
Grade:
Overall (dub) : C
Overall (sub) : C
Story : C-
Animation : C+
Art : C
Music : C+
+ Satisfying character development for Guise and especially Jean
− Otherwise pointless, for completionists only
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
Gunslinger Girl OVA DVD review,
new anime,
the anime review,
top anime
The Anime Review : El Cazador de la Bruja DVD - Season 1 Part 2
Synopsis:
A little wiser, a little more wary, but no less determined to make their way to Wiñay Marka, Nadie and Ellis continue south. As their chance partnership slowly deepens into something richer and more important than either would readily admit, neither is aware that even that factors into the nefarious scheme brewing inside government scientist Douglas Rosenberg's rotten skull. Unfortunately for him, other kinds of rot—namely his rotten dealings with rotten politicians—end up derailing his scheme when his corrupt political support, as corrupt political support is wont to do, gets caught in a corruption sweep. Which changes Nadie and Ellis's situation irrevocably. With no one to protect Ellis from, Blue-eyes calls in Nadie, intending to take her off Ellis's case and Ellis into custody. Nadie, of course, refuses. Prompting Blue-eyes' handlers to come down on the pair hard. And if that—and a journey to an unknown destination—weren't enough, they haven't yet heard the last of Rosenberg...or his creepy sidekick L.A.
Review:
All directors have their little quirks and obsessions. Alfred Hitchcock had his icy blondes, John Woo has his doves, and Koichi Mashimo, apparently, has his masked perverts and their evil rituals involving underage girls. Guess who ends this series bedecked in a glorified poncho and faux-Aztec headdress/helmet? No prizes for guessing Rosenberg.
Though calling what is essentially a po-faced sight gag an obsession is a stretch. It's more a reflection of the series' wry self-awareness than a directorial trademark. The lackadaisical good humor of Bruja's two leads, it seems, is quite infectious. Like Nadie and Ellis the series approaches every development with a secret smile and imperturbable calm. So good-natured is it that even its most elaborate cliché-dumps (and they get very elaborate) can be greeted with a chuckle rather than a grimace. Even in its final leg the series remains light and unhurried, an antidote, really, for the overwrought operatism of things like Madlax.
Of course, this being the end of the series, not all is wisecracking femmes and self-effacing parody. There are far more little threads of continuity running through the second half's standalone tales than ever there were in the first. There are Rosenberg's schemes and L.A.'s quest to free himself from them, the conspiracy of witches and Blue-eyes' ambitions, and, most importantly, Ellis's slow humanization. It's nice to see the secondary characters—Ricardo and especially Blue-eyes, but even L.A—finally stop floating through the series and start exerting an influence, but the real treat, growth-wise, is definitely Ellis. She's always been great, unflappable fun, but her illogical calm only becomes a full-fledged personality trait here as she accumulates emotions and relationships. There's a warmth to the little jokes about her personality that can only be described as satisfaction, perhaps even pride, at her maturation. Nadie on the other hand—aside from her deepening feelings for Ellis—doesn't change. But that's all right. She doesn't need to.
Of course, this also being El Cazador de la Bruja, such developments naturally happen in the most stubbornly episodic fashion possible. Continuous and even serious those plot threads may be, but they are firmly embedded within one-off stories about part-time taco-slinging and live vulture hunting. Even Ellis's emotional growth is episodic, happening as it does in short stories that may as well have titles like "Ellis Gets Mad," "Ellis Gets Jealous," or "Ellis and Nadie Have a Fight." Which is actually a lot more enjoyable than it sounds. The episodic structure works in the series' favor, keeping Bee Train's tendencies towards draggy drear firmly in check by containing the action to a single episode and focusing often on the silly or frivolous in Nadie and Ellis's journey. Add in a whiff of direction thanks to those trailing plot threads, and you have a firm good time.
Technically speaking the series remains rock-steady. Not rock-steady as in good, but rock-steady as in consistent. All of the series'—and indeed the studio's—trademarks make their way unblemished into the second half: the indulgent desert vistas are positively gorgeous, the action is sparing but expertly and fluidly staged, the pans over eyes and skewed, static compositions are long and slow, and the characters look better than perhaps any in the Bee Train oeuvre. The girls are the obvious draw, and wiry, athletic Nadie is an undeniable treat (those are some seriously cool boots), but the series' sexiest character may well be Ricardo with his granite good looks, flinty Eastwood stare, and Charles Bronson 'stache. Or maybe that's just me.
Yuki Kajiura 's score is big, pretty and curiously good-humored. Keep an ear out for Ennio Morricone pastiches and a musical wink to Lowell Lo's iconic score for The Killer.
Funimation 's dub displays flawless judgment. That is inarguable. But there's a slight limpness to it that hints that, while ADR director Christopher Bevin's brain is in it, his heart is not. That limpness was a little worm of worry throughout the first set, easily banished by the hammy villains that the dub graciously offered up as distraction. But as the major secondary characters take over, the worm grows into a rather conspicuous snake. Not that any are objectively poor—merely...off, as if in its determination to respect the original, the dub missed the joke: that the original doesn't respect itself. And with the joke goes much of the original's color.
Another episode-long commentary—with Bevins again, along with Ian Sinclair (Rosenberg) and Clarine Harp (Blue-eyes)—is the set's big extra. As per usual, as fun and dirt-filled as you could want (random fact: apparently Dragon Ball is really hard on actors).
Heading into its second half Bruja delves far more deeply into the explicitly supernatural and flirts copiously with shojo-ai. It's also a smidge less fun and a good deal more satisfying than previously. Nevertheless, the deciding factor in whether you will or will not enjoy Bruja's second half will very simply be whether you enjoyed its first. After all, its main draws—sly wit, great chemistry, and siesta-time pacing—remain absolutely unchanged. As do its deterrents (hello plot lines from ye 'ol slag heap o' pseudoscientific anime nonsense). Unhook that brain and enjoy the ride.
Grade:
Overall (dub) : C+
Overall (sub) : B-
Story : C+
Animation : B-
Art : B
Music : B
+ Great leads, high fun factor, and a real conclusion, complete with episode-long coda; more cohesive than the first half.
− Also a little less fun and a bit darker; ultimately disposable.
A little wiser, a little more wary, but no less determined to make their way to Wiñay Marka, Nadie and Ellis continue south. As their chance partnership slowly deepens into something richer and more important than either would readily admit, neither is aware that even that factors into the nefarious scheme brewing inside government scientist Douglas Rosenberg's rotten skull. Unfortunately for him, other kinds of rot—namely his rotten dealings with rotten politicians—end up derailing his scheme when his corrupt political support, as corrupt political support is wont to do, gets caught in a corruption sweep. Which changes Nadie and Ellis's situation irrevocably. With no one to protect Ellis from, Blue-eyes calls in Nadie, intending to take her off Ellis's case and Ellis into custody. Nadie, of course, refuses. Prompting Blue-eyes' handlers to come down on the pair hard. And if that—and a journey to an unknown destination—weren't enough, they haven't yet heard the last of Rosenberg...or his creepy sidekick L.A.
Review:
All directors have their little quirks and obsessions. Alfred Hitchcock had his icy blondes, John Woo has his doves, and Koichi Mashimo, apparently, has his masked perverts and their evil rituals involving underage girls. Guess who ends this series bedecked in a glorified poncho and faux-Aztec headdress/helmet? No prizes for guessing Rosenberg.
Though calling what is essentially a po-faced sight gag an obsession is a stretch. It's more a reflection of the series' wry self-awareness than a directorial trademark. The lackadaisical good humor of Bruja's two leads, it seems, is quite infectious. Like Nadie and Ellis the series approaches every development with a secret smile and imperturbable calm. So good-natured is it that even its most elaborate cliché-dumps (and they get very elaborate) can be greeted with a chuckle rather than a grimace. Even in its final leg the series remains light and unhurried, an antidote, really, for the overwrought operatism of things like Madlax.
Of course, this being the end of the series, not all is wisecracking femmes and self-effacing parody. There are far more little threads of continuity running through the second half's standalone tales than ever there were in the first. There are Rosenberg's schemes and L.A.'s quest to free himself from them, the conspiracy of witches and Blue-eyes' ambitions, and, most importantly, Ellis's slow humanization. It's nice to see the secondary characters—Ricardo and especially Blue-eyes, but even L.A—finally stop floating through the series and start exerting an influence, but the real treat, growth-wise, is definitely Ellis. She's always been great, unflappable fun, but her illogical calm only becomes a full-fledged personality trait here as she accumulates emotions and relationships. There's a warmth to the little jokes about her personality that can only be described as satisfaction, perhaps even pride, at her maturation. Nadie on the other hand—aside from her deepening feelings for Ellis—doesn't change. But that's all right. She doesn't need to.
Of course, this also being El Cazador de la Bruja, such developments naturally happen in the most stubbornly episodic fashion possible. Continuous and even serious those plot threads may be, but they are firmly embedded within one-off stories about part-time taco-slinging and live vulture hunting. Even Ellis's emotional growth is episodic, happening as it does in short stories that may as well have titles like "Ellis Gets Mad," "Ellis Gets Jealous," or "Ellis and Nadie Have a Fight." Which is actually a lot more enjoyable than it sounds. The episodic structure works in the series' favor, keeping Bee Train's tendencies towards draggy drear firmly in check by containing the action to a single episode and focusing often on the silly or frivolous in Nadie and Ellis's journey. Add in a whiff of direction thanks to those trailing plot threads, and you have a firm good time.
Technically speaking the series remains rock-steady. Not rock-steady as in good, but rock-steady as in consistent. All of the series'—and indeed the studio's—trademarks make their way unblemished into the second half: the indulgent desert vistas are positively gorgeous, the action is sparing but expertly and fluidly staged, the pans over eyes and skewed, static compositions are long and slow, and the characters look better than perhaps any in the Bee Train oeuvre. The girls are the obvious draw, and wiry, athletic Nadie is an undeniable treat (those are some seriously cool boots), but the series' sexiest character may well be Ricardo with his granite good looks, flinty Eastwood stare, and Charles Bronson 'stache. Or maybe that's just me.
Yuki Kajiura 's score is big, pretty and curiously good-humored. Keep an ear out for Ennio Morricone pastiches and a musical wink to Lowell Lo's iconic score for The Killer.
Funimation 's dub displays flawless judgment. That is inarguable. But there's a slight limpness to it that hints that, while ADR director Christopher Bevin's brain is in it, his heart is not. That limpness was a little worm of worry throughout the first set, easily banished by the hammy villains that the dub graciously offered up as distraction. But as the major secondary characters take over, the worm grows into a rather conspicuous snake. Not that any are objectively poor—merely...off, as if in its determination to respect the original, the dub missed the joke: that the original doesn't respect itself. And with the joke goes much of the original's color.
Another episode-long commentary—with Bevins again, along with Ian Sinclair (Rosenberg) and Clarine Harp (Blue-eyes)—is the set's big extra. As per usual, as fun and dirt-filled as you could want (random fact: apparently Dragon Ball is really hard on actors).
Heading into its second half Bruja delves far more deeply into the explicitly supernatural and flirts copiously with shojo-ai. It's also a smidge less fun and a good deal more satisfying than previously. Nevertheless, the deciding factor in whether you will or will not enjoy Bruja's second half will very simply be whether you enjoyed its first. After all, its main draws—sly wit, great chemistry, and siesta-time pacing—remain absolutely unchanged. As do its deterrents (hello plot lines from ye 'ol slag heap o' pseudoscientific anime nonsense). Unhook that brain and enjoy the ride.
Grade:
Overall (dub) : C+
Overall (sub) : B-
Story : C+
Animation : B-
Art : B
Music : B
+ Great leads, high fun factor, and a real conclusion, complete with episode-long coda; more cohesive than the first half.
− Also a little less fun and a bit darker; ultimately disposable.
Labels:
anime review 2010,
anime reviews,
best anime,
comic 2010 review,
comic book review,
comic review,
comics review,
El Cazador de la Bruja review,
new anime,
the anime review,
top anime
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



